Analyzing Product Composition: Deciphering Your Cosmetic Ingredients
Équipe éditoriale
This article guides you step-by-step to analyze the composition of a cosmetic product: understanding the structure of the INCI list, identifying skin-supporting ingredients, spotting those that require more attention, and using the right tools before purchase.
The Devoghe® gesture
The gesture to adopt
Practical advice to help your readers go further.
Analyzing the ingredient list of your cosmetics
The INCI list is the identity card of a cosmetic product. Knowing how to read it allows you to understand what a formula truly contains, beyond the promises on the packaging. To delve deeper into online cosmetic composition analysis, some tools offer a more detailed reading than a simple label observation.
Understanding the order of the INCI list
Mandatory in Europe since 1998, the INCI list must appear on the packaging of all cosmetics sold, including on e-commerce sites. To understand the general composition of a cosmetic product, it is important to know that ingredients are listed in decreasing order of concentration down to a threshold of 1%. Below this threshold, their order can vary freely. The first three to five ingredients generally represent up to 80% of the formula and reveal its framework.
- Ranks 1 to 5: these include the essential components of the product: water (Aqua), humectants, fatty substances, or texture agents. They directly influence the feel, texture, and hydration profile of the product.
- Ranks 6 to 10: functional active ingredients such as Niacinamide, Panthenol, or Sodium Hyaluronate are often found here, present in concentrations between approximately 1% and 5%. Their concentration can therefore remain significant for the skin.
- Beyond the 10th rank: the concentration frequently falls below 1%. Preservatives, fragrance, declared allergens, and colorants identified by "CI" followed by five digits often appear in this section.
- An active ingredient highlighted on the bottle: if it appears far down the list, its concentration is likely less than 1%, which may limit its impact on the skin.
In its investigations on the requirement for clear information on cosmetic composition, the DGCCRF noted that approximately 29% of websites checked in 2018 showed labeling anomalies. Checking the list therefore remains a useful step before any purchase.
Recognizing ingredients beneficial to the skin
For sensitive skin, the first ten ingredients are particularly informative. Glycerin, Panthenol, Niacinamide, Sodium Hyaluronate, or Ceramide NP can contribute to hydration, comfort, and support the skin barrier. This observation applies to all ingredients listed before the 1% threshold. To understand how to decipher an INCI list, a methodical reading is often enough to distinguish a balanced formula from a more complex composition.
A natural INCI ingredient generally refers to an extract of plant or botanical origin, recognizable by its Latin name, such as Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract or Butyrospermum Parkii Butter. Vegetable oils often carry the mention "seed oil." These terms indicate an origin, but do not specify the concentration or the actual tolerance for your skin. These two criteria are as important as the source.
Distinguishing naturalness from formula quality
A natural ingredient is not automatically better tolerated, while a synthetic component is not necessarily problematic. Paraffinum Liquidum and Petrolatum, for example, are film-forming mineral oils: they do not provide nutrients to the skin and are not biodegradable. Their presence at the top of the list is worth noting, without concluding a systematic problem depending on the type of product. ANSES reminds us of the importance of carefully reading the composition of cosmetic products to identify substances that may pose a risk, especially for people prone to allergies.
Aggressive sulfates, parabens like butyl- or propylparaben, formaldehyde releasers like DMDM Hydantoin, and synthetic fragrance, often grouped under "Parfum" or "Fragrance," deserve particular attention. The latter can cover several allergenic molecules. Silicones are notably recognized by their -cone, -conol, or -siloxane endings; cyclic silicones D4, D5, and D6 are classified by the European Union as persistent and bioaccumulative substances. These elements are evaluated by regulatory authorities, but it remains useful to know which ones your skin tolerates best.
Choosing an application to analyze cosmetics
Several tools now allow you to analyze an INCI list without prior expertise. INCI Decoder, CosDNA, and Open Beauty Facts offer copy-paste analysis, based on databases referencing up to 15,000 ingredients. CosDNA associates each component with comedogenicity, allergenicity, and risk level indicators.
Mobile applications like Yuka or INCI Beauty work by barcode scanning. Yuka takes a precautionary approach, while INCI Beauty provides more regulatory context. For an official INCI search, CosIng, the European Commission's database, allows you to verify the function, CAS number, and legal restrictions of each ingredient according to EC Regulation 1223/2009.
Their scores remain reading indicators, however, not a verdict on the absolute safety of a formula. Cosmetic regulation in France already governs the market placement of each product. Personal analysis complements this framework without replacing it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which application reliably analyzes cosmetic ingredients?
Several applications allow you to decipher an INCI list from a phone. Yuka and INCI Beauty offer barcode scanning and assign a score based on the ingredients added to the formula: preservatives, fragrance, allergens, or suspected endocrine disruptors. Yuka adopts a cautious approach, while INCI Beauty provides more regulatory context.
For a more comprehensive copy-paste analysis, INCI Decoder and CosDNA allow you to examine each component of the formula, particularly from the perspective of comedogenicity and allergenicity. An ingredient assessed as sensitive in a database may be suitable in a specific usage context. Furthermore, no application knows the exact proportions of the recipe: the scope of an automatic rating therefore remains limited.
How do you quickly analyze an INCI list without an application?
To analyze a list without a digital tool, start with the first three to five ingredients. They generally represent up to 80% of the formula and provide a first indication of the product's focus. The presence of Glycerin, Panthenol, or Sodium Hyaluronate in a good position suggests a formula aimed at hydration and skin comfort.
Then observe sulfates, denatured alcohol, or synthetic fragrance when they appear at the beginning of the list: their position may signal lower tolerance for sensitive skin. Also compare the position of an active ingredient highlighted on the packaging with its actual position in the INCI list. If it appears at the end of the list, its concentration is likely less than 1%. This reading helps to determine if the formula matches your skin's needs and to avoid a composition whose framework deviates from the stated claims.
What tool should be used to verify the safety of cosmetic ingredients?
For official verification, CosIng, the European Commission's database, lists all authorized cosmetic ingredients, their function, and restrictions provided by EC Regulation 1223/2009. This is a useful reference for a serious INCI search.
To broaden the analysis to environmental and health impact, the EWG system relies on nearly 60 databases dedicated to toxicity and regulatory requirements. It assigns a rating from 1 to 10. BIODIZIONARIO, for its part, offers five evaluation levels, from "safe" to "not recommended."
However, the level of risk depends on the methodology used by each tool. The same component can therefore receive different scores depending on the platform. In case of persistent or unusual skin reaction after using cosmetics, it is better to consult a health professional rather than relying solely on an application.
